Another episode, another batch of excellent performances and spirited writing. What did I think?
WARNING! SPOILERS BELOW! YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED!
This is one of those episodes that leaves me with more questions than answers... lots of questions actually:
- So is Caprica Boomer choosing sides? Is she in love with Helo and that is why she says "everything has changed?"
- Is the herbal/alternative cancer treatment giving Roslin the gift of prophecy or were the visions a convenient plot device?
- When did Starbuck become sympathetic to Leobon? Was she really so easily won over by some ditch psychoanalysis about her family?
- Can anyone explain the scene with Adama in the morgue? Was he questioning his own humanity?
- Is the doctor going to tell anyone about Galactica Boomer?
- Hell, I agree with Number Six, why is she called Boomer?
- Watch the deleted scenes... what's with the transponder?
So yeah... my mind is spinning. This was one of the more emotionally complex episodes to come along seeing how it had to deal with the moral issues of torture, competing religious blueprints (mono, poly), the philosophy of what constitutes humanity, what constitutes a soul... these are some ambitious stories.
As I was watching, I was convinced that the nuclear bomb was going to be 'inside' Leobon and that they would flush him out of the airlock to save the day... that was not the case. What resulted was a showdown that was much more nuanced, much more anti-climatic yet still revealing.
President Roslin's moment of clarity and immediate action was a welcome surprise. The final scene is setup for her to show pity and compassion. Her snap judgment and summary execution really turned those final moments on it's head and reinforces how important she is to the human cause of survival. She may not command Galactica but she is running the show. Just when the writers set us up to think she doesn't have the guts to make the tough calls, she makes them.
The chemistry between Starbuck and Leobon is excellent. Starbuck stays true to her no nonsense attitude and rarely lets Leobon get the best of her. In the end, I found her compassion in the airlock a little out of character. I feel like I missed the crucial moment when she went from hating him, to pitying his fear. I guess it was meant to show her humanity after committing acts of torture. I found it ironic that Leobon convicted her of dehumanizing him, especially since he actually isn't human... the Cylons do a pretty good job dehumanizing themselves with their own actions.
The MVP of the episode has to go to Callem Keith Rennie and the Leobon character. His performance of a tortured Cylon really made the entire episode work. Without a strong commitment to his character, I don't think the drama of the episode would have been nearly as effective. I still don't get his hold over Starbuck, but I blame that more on the writers than his performance.
It will be interesting to see how Starbuck's sympathy for the Cylon soul plays out going forward. It has been quite enjoyable seeing the show wrestle with religion, its many flavors and flaws. Having Starbuck a more central character in this discussion can only be a good thing given her strong will and seemly clear tactical mind. Science fiction is always at its best when using abstract stories to frame and offer new perspective on common social debates. Religious fanaticism is as worthy of this 'new perspective' as any.
Make sure to check out the deleted scenes and the episode summary at the official website.