I know there are a ton of reviews of Battlestar Galactica out there, but this one by R. Jason Bennion of the Simple Tricks and Nonsense blog is a really extensive and solid critique... maybe because he is a writer. His beast of a blog post spans three whole entries:
Neo-Galactica, Part 1
"I've thought a lot over the past few weeks about remakes, or "reimaginings," as TV and movie producers have pretentiously taken to calling them. They're nothing new, of course -- updating older entertainment properties for a new generation has been a common industry practice since at least the early sound era, when a number of prominent silent films were redone as talkies. These days, however, there seem to be a lot more of them being made than there used to be."
Neo-Galactica, Part 2: The Rant
"Before I proceed with my long-promised review of the new Battlestar Galactica remake series, there's something I want to get off my chest: I am really sick and tired of the way every article I read about the new show starts out by trashing the original series. What is it about American culture that we can't complement one thing without denigrating something else? It's almost like one of Newton's laws -- for every positive word spoken there must be an equal and opposite insult."
Neo-Galactica, Part 3: The Review (At Last!)
"I like it. -- I didn't think I would. I even tried not to, out of loyalty to the series that I grew up with and still enjoy. But in the end (and to my surprise), I find that I actually do like the new Battlestar Galactica. It's a good series on its own terms, and it's also the rare example of a remake that improves on the original by taking it seriously."
"That's not to say, however, that I like it without reservation. There are aspects of it that don't quite work for me, and, as I've already mentioned a couple of times, I'm not at all comfortable with the fact that this show is on track to replace the original in our collective pop-cultural memories. Nevertheless, I can't deny that Ron Moore, the driving force behind the remake, has created something that is honestly worthy of the attention the show is receiving."
The whole trilogy is a pretty huge read, but it is a very well thought opinion and I think that deserves recognition. If there is one thing this world is short of, it is well thought opinions.