You know Kevin Smith right? The guy who made Clerks and Mallrats and all those other crazy films? He has a big rave on his site about BSG this week:
Without changing much of the original “Galactica” premise, the
creators and folks involved with the show have done the equivalent of
taking a covered wagon and creating a BMW from the design: it still
takes you from place to place, but now it does so while keeping you
safe from the elements, getting you there quicker, warming your ass
with heated, leather seats, and bathing your ears in audio delights
from an iPod-friendly sound-system. With the mini-series alone, these
people managed to not simply just teach an old dog new tricks; they
taught that bitch to speak, travel to alternate dimensions, fold space,
and cure cancer.
How was this accomplished? How did the new
“B-Star G” peeps spin straw into gold? How did they make the human
beings as interesting (if not more so) than the fucking Cylons? Like
all great art, they simply held a mirror up to our culture. “Galactica”
V.2 is an allegory for 9/11 and the War on Terror viewed from both
sides. It offers a far more complex view of two opposite ideologies in
juxtaposition to one another, presenting neither side as particularly
evil – just terrifying. Extremely well done Science Fiction has always
been most powerfully effective when it lays out humanity naked and
shows us ourselves, warts and all. Whether it’s “Planet of the Apes”,
“Star Trek”, or almost anything by Phillip K. Dick, the best sci-fi
isn’t simply laser-beam driven shoot-‘em-ups between good guys and bad
guys; it’s the abyss we look into and see someone awfully, sometimes
painfully familiar looking back from. There will always be a place in
Science Fiction for the Joseph Campbell-described archetypical hero’s
journey of the “Star Wars” saga, but what Sci-Fi does best is allow the
author to comment on what it’s like to be a human being – the shame,
the miracle, the sacrifice, the desire, the grand heights, and the
abject lows. And if an author can accomplish this in stealth mode – be
entertaining while not calling attention to his or her loftier goals –
so much the better.
Read more
It look like we have ourselves another convert! Woo hoo!
Kevin says on his blog that he does "hours of web-investigation on the subject" so if you happen to stop by, HI KEVIN!